History and GovernmentSupreme CourtCases

Board of Estimate of City of New York v. Morris (1989)

Case Summary

Morris and others who lived and voted in Brooklyn, the most populous borough of New York City, claimed that the method of electing members of the Board of Estimate violated the Equal Protection Clause, because representation was not proportional to population. The trial court found for Morris. The Court of Appeals affirmed, and the City then appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Court's Decision

The Supreme Court ruled that the composition of the Board violated the Equal Protection Clause, because each borough has equal representation despite wide disparities in population. Justice Byron White wrote for the six-judge majority. Three other justices concurred in the result but differed with specific parts of the analysis.

Justice White began by observing that the constitutional rule of “one-person, one-vote” applies to local government as well as to State and congressional elections. He then reviewed the functions of the Board of Estimate—which include a role in formulating New York City's budget of over $25 billion, plus management of city property, setting city salaries, and granting all city contracts—to show that the Board exercises significant legislative functions. The Board's “powers are general enough and have sufficient impact throughout the district to require that elections to the body comply with equal protection strictures.”

The Court rejected the city's argument that the special structure of the Board was “essential to the successful government of…the City of New York…[because it] accommodates natural and political boundaries as well as local interests.” Although the Court did not say that these political and geographical interests could never be considered, it held that they would not justify the large deviation in voting strength that was present in the case.

More on the Case

As a result of the decision in Morris, New York City modified its Charter to eliminate the Board of Estimate as a governmental body. Many of the Board's powers were transferred to the Mayor; the City Council was expanded and its powers were enlarged as well. The role of the boroughs in municipal government was reduced.

Other localities have found creative ways to structure their elective bodies in compliance with Morris while preserving geographical and political boundaries. Delaware County is one of New York's sixty-two counties, with a 1990 census population of about 50,000 spread over nineteen towns. The smallest town, Bovina, had 550 residents, the largest, Sidney, had 6,667. The County is governed by a nineteen-person Board of Supervisors, with one member elected from each town. However, unlike the situation in Morris, Delaware County gave each Board member a weighted vote that closely matches the relative population in his or her town. For example, Sidney has about 12 times the population of Bovina, so Sidney's representative is allocated approximately 12 times the voting power. This arrangement was found constitutional under the Morris analysis by the United States Court of Appeals in Roxbury Taxpayers Alliance v. Delaware County Board of Supervisors, 1996.

Source: ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. Used by permission.

Information Please®, ©2005 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Special Books for the Kids You Love
Celebrate 20 years of sharing love to the moon and back with the anniversary edition of Guess How Much I Love You, one of the world’s best-loved picture books. Plus, search our Book Finder for more great book picks. Brought to you by Candlewick Press.

Vote Now for the Children's & Teen Choice Book Awards
Voting is open now through May 3 for the Children's and Teen Choice Book Awards — the only national book awards program where the winning author, illustrator, and books of the year are selected by young readers. Encourage your child to vote for his favorites today!

Top 10 Math & Science Apps for Your Whiz Kid
Looking for the best math and science apps for kids? Check out these cool apps for all ages, which will grow your child's love of the STEM subjects (science, technology, engineering, and math).

Registered for Kindergarten — Now What?
Wondering what to do now that you've signed your child up for kindergarten? Try our award-winning Kindergarten Readiness app! This easy-to-use checklist comes with games and activities to help your child build essential skills for kindergarten. Download the Kindergarten Readiness app today!

stay connected

Sign up for our free email newsletters and receive the latest advice and information on all things parenting.

Enter your email address to sign up or manage your account.

Facebook icon Facebook icon Follow Us on Pinterest

editor’s picks